5 Comments
User's avatar
Eric Brown's avatar

I’m sure you’re aware of Michael Flynn’s Great Ptolemaic Smackdown:

https://tofspot.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-great-ptolemaic-smackdown.html

Expand full comment
thinking-turtle's avatar

Thanks for sharing! It's a great but lengthy read. I didn't know stars have a diameter when seen through a telescope, and that it was only discovered in the 19th century that this was an optical illusion.

Expand full comment
John Plaice's avatar

Thanks for the link. I was not familiar with Flynn's essay. I'll read it carefully.

Expand full comment
Al's avatar

Mr. Plaice,

It'd be wonderful to hear you address the divisive concept of a flat Earth. I happen to fall on the oblate spheroid side of the discussion, but am not an organized, formal, deep scholar as you and those whose works you plumb (and my brighter brothers) are.

Also, others' articles make reference to an Earth with an unevenly distributed, lumpy, "potato-shaped" gravitational field. Do you have any views or historical scholarship on that? (On an oblate tuber, or something?)

This site is riveting, even to one who understands maybe half of, it on a good day.

Thanks,

Al

Expand full comment
Merlinstruction.com's avatar

Been a few years since I read Schachts model and was fully convinced, especially by the geometric forms of it, and it's similarity to the magnetic field lines along the plane of inertia

Expand full comment